Pages


Thursday, December 30, 2010

Housekeeping

I'm taking down all my tabs with animation on it for now, mainly because I haven't yet figured out how public I want this blog to be. When my reel's ready, I'll put it up on my personal website, obviously, but this term ended with a lot of unfinished work and I'm taking a step back right this instant to focus on fundamentals. The plan for the next few weeks while I'm home with my family in Salt Lake City is a) get my new Macbook Pro set up, and b) re-learn how to draw.

The Mac turned into a time sink because I didn't know about the Maya 2011/Mac Quicktime playblast bug - audio sync is off unless you playblast from Frame 1. This is unacceptable as far as I'm concerned, but rather than go back to Maya 2010, I'm going to write a command line app to work around the bug and generate a properly sync'd Quicktime movie. So far I've been taking the scenic route in trying to figure out the Mac architecture and development environment, but I should pick up speed soon.

The drawing is going to be an ongoing process. I want to get my fundamentals solid enough to do 2D pencil tests, which means breaking some very old habits. I'll probably be using the blog to get feedback, but right now I'm still just reading books and trying to come up with a game plan.

Monday, November 29, 2010

Internet Lockdown

This might be my last blog post till the end of AM. Basically, I discovered that pulling my Ethernet cable did wonders for my productivity. I'll still be checking email and such, but probably once per day rather than every 5 seconds.

The goal is to get through the rest of this shot in the next two weeks. This week's assignment submission wasn't  perfect, but I feel like I learned what I needed to know. I had my spine epiphany earlier, and I also recognize a couple of the biggest traps I fall into:

1) Getting distracted (by Facebook, email, youtube)
2) Polishing graph editor curves instead of the animation, resulting in mushy timing
3) Focusing too much on screen space rather than 3D space

So what I need to do right now is TRUST that everything my friends have taught me has finally sunk into my head, trust that I really do know how to animate, trust that the spine epiphany was real, and just GET THE HELL THROUGH THE REST OF THE SHOT.

Obviously, I'll come up for air for feedback, but probably by emailing people directly or through the AM site. So this blog's part of the Internet lockdown for now. See you in two weeks!

Tuesday, November 23, 2010

Fallout

This has been a strange week. I needed some time to regroup before posting. Basically, I had a lot of fun socializing, submitted my worst assignment ever, and am now wondering if I need to rethink the self-punishment thing.

The voices in my head I'm hearing right now are the supportive ones, not the ones that kick you when you're down. Even the Peer Buddy who honestly said, "I kinda liked it better the old way" - that's useful feedback that's sometimes difficult to give and absolutely belongs in the supportive category. So I'm not upset as I would have been previously, but will that lead to better or worse animating this week?

A couple side factors: I was and am borderline sick on and off throughout the week, but that may be because my careful nutrition and allergy management routine was thrown off by socializing and the usual December germs. There's no way I would have missed the CTN Expo happy hour on Friday or my out-of-town friend's pre-Thanksgiving gathering on Saturday, but I'd been feeling lousy on Tuesday and under different circumstances would probably have blown off the weekend plans. This week continues to be slow-moving - I swear I've been asleep more than I've been awake the last two days, and I'm still feeling fatigued. Maybe this is punishment for being careless about the allergy mangement, I'm not sure. I did stick to my usual exercise schedule, but it hasn't given me my usual energy boost and I could definitely feel that something was off today when I went into the gym. The workout did help some, though, so hopefully I'm on the right track in terms of recovering my routine.

Plans for this week are real simple - go stepped wherever I feel myself starting to noodle, don't spend more than a day on that troublesome first section, and make my way through the entire rest of my shot. I know I phoned it in last week, and I know I can do better, but it's almost strange to dig deep by thinking of the supportive circle. In some was, fear/anger/resentment was the much better motivator, at least until it almost broke me.

Tuesday, November 16, 2010

Two Birthday Gifts

Two cool birthday gifts this year:

One is that my mom's buying me a souped-up Macbook Pro and I'm spending the last of my AM student discount on the software for it. Woohoo!

The second... It's a gift to self, really, and perhaps harder to live up to - but I'm going to stop punishing myself on Sundays and start celebrating progress, however small or incomplete. This really does go all the way back to Jerkass in Class 3, who kept insisting that I was getting complacent whenever I dared to be happy about something. I'll never really know whether he was being actively malicious or just mistaken, but it did cast a long shadow over the rest of my time at AM. Basically, I internalized the attitude that if I didn't completely hate myself on Sundays, I must not be working hard enough.

He was completely hypocritical about this, of course. One of his more charming habits was to leave meaningless flattery on the workspaces of people he sniped about in private, in order to get meaningless flattery in return. And he sulked royally whenever a mentor or the teeming masses didn't appreciate his brilliance, which, strangely enough, happened more and more frequently in the later classes as the mentors go tougher. Again, it's spectacularly obvious in hindsight that I should have rid myself of this person long before I actually did, but no one's a complete jerk right off the bat. In real life, you can judge a person in the context of their community. In a virtual community like AM, it sometimes takes a little longer, but the truth does come out in the end.

Anyway, that's my birthday gift to self this year: to celebrate any and all progress, no matter how small, and quit with the self-punishment and self-doubt. This has to continue after AM, of course. I won't be done with my reel at the end of Class 6. But neither will I collapse at the finish line - I plan to keep right on going.

Monday, November 15, 2010

Notes from Catherine

Notes from Catherine below. I'm just adding some whitespace here so the jpg doesn't get lost behind the sidebar.











I'm commenting on your week 7 assignment. I think I mention something about shoulder head turning at the same time. but something else jumped into my eyes....the eyes :)
If you turn you head you almost (no rules of course) blink every time you do a turn otherwise you would feel queasy. added a picture to explain how I would do the drag and blink.

When the coach turns back F74, what about fix the kid a bit longer with the eyes. my impression is that the head and shoulder is moving together more that it should to make it dynamic.
also maybe you have to many ideas there. 1. looking to the kid 2. looking thoughtful in the air. 3. looking at the board.
Think it would be simpler 1. and then " blink" direct to 3.

Sunday, November 14, 2010

A Burial

Not that I'm afraid of naming names, but as I've gotten older I've learned some measure of descretion, so let's introduce a new character we'll call Jerkass for short.

Some of you know Jerkass, as he was a classmate at AM. Some of you thought he was a twit from the beginning (hello, Fiona). Why did I ever befriend Jerkass? In hindsight, because I was cynical and didn't trust or know to trust AM and the AM community. So when Jerkass sniped behind peoples' backs about how our classmates were lazy or weren't going to make it, and constructed a color-coded spreadsheet of who the desirable mentors were based on the prestige of their studio, I kind of agreed.

This is not the side of me that most of you know. Anyone reading this blog has probably seen me give good crits, empathy, and encouragement. I may not always have known much about animation, but what I had, I had to share.

That said, I definitely entered AM under a cloud. Being away from production for eight months has mellowed me considerably and allowed me to remember the good times, of which there were many, but the stress and frustration of being a TD were very real to me at the time. The image I had in my head of the work I was doing was cormorant fishing - you know, the birds with a string tied around their neck so they can't swallow and instead have to bring the fish they catch back to the fisherman. I was there strictly as support staff for artists, and it drove me crazy to be doing the scutwork with no chance at the reward.

Yes, I did eventually get to do some crowds shot work. No, I was never treated unfairly by either of the studios I worked for. This is absolutely not about those companies or my coworkers. It's simply about my personal state of mind at the time I started AM, and why I was angry, tired, and cynical enough to find Jerkass's attitude appealing.

The rest is rather sad history - we were good friends through Classes 1 and 2, and then he turned on me in Class 3. I still have miles-long emails from him about how awful an animator I am, how I'm not going to make it, and how he feels sorry for me, interspersed with megolomanic ranting about how great he is. I'm not making this up, and I have the paper trail to prove it, but it's absolutely not worth revisiting. The really sad part is that in all that verbiage, there was next to no useful information - he'd say something like "I don't see the principles of animation in your work" with no further explanation.

For obvious reasons, I stopped talking to him by Class 4, but by then the damage was done - I'd become very, very gun-shy of legitimate crits. I always was, unfortunately, but this made it a lot worse because each crit was suddenly no longer just a crit, it was an assessment of whether or not I was going to make it.

I did my best to pull myself out from underneath that cloud. Being a peer buddy myself, leaning on peer buddies, reconnecting with old friends, and making new ones were all as important to me as the animation itself, these past three terms. But it was always a struggle not to sink into despair, and I don't think I ever really felt like myself again until now, almost at the end of Class 6.

I have a lot of work left to do after graduation. I know that. But I won the important moral victory with the help of you guys: I still love to animate and I finally believe in myself again.

Chasing The Dream

Spine's still not all the way there yet, but screw it, today I'm just going to celebrate what I did right rather than fixate on everything that's still left to fix. Feedback welcome of course. :)

Sunday, November 7, 2010

Midway Through

I worked on the first 135 frames this week, but ended up only submitting the first 62 because they were the biggest time sink and the later section was just too rough. Next week I plan on hooking everything up, right through to the end of the kid skitter. Body mechanics and spine overlap are killing me - I keep getting closer without quite hitting that sweet spot.

With graduation is looming, I sometimes feel like I'm having the same conversations over and over with outside friends, explaining to people that it's meaningless to the jobhunt and is therefore a date to be dreaded, as you lose access to the school's resources.

Looking back, I was miserable at my Princeton graduation (three full days of pomp and circumstance), and I never even finished at GWU. Princeton at the time felt like a failure, with comparative literature a dead end (I didn't have a crystal ball to tell me I'd figure out computer science on my own), and I forget at times how burned out and exhausted I was after GWU - Digital Domain hired me not knowing how much I hated computer science by then! And yet DD revived me - I finally discovered my inner rock star. No regrets there.

Point being, personal history tells me that I'll keep right on chugging after graduation rather than collapsing, but god knows I wish I were soaring across rather than limping across the finish line. There will be more shots in the future - my revamped chair dance definitely, perhaps the juggler, but maybe I'll do some really simple Stewie tests first, to master the simple stuff before leaping back into the complicated stuff.

I'm so close - I'll win this battle yet, even if it's not on the timeline I would have desired.

Thursday, November 4, 2010

Frame 1

The version addressing Greg's Q&A notes. Much improved if I do say so myself. One (mostly) approved frame in only two weeks time, am I good or am I good?



I suspect that as I animate, I'll have a tendancy to subconsciously dial back the coach's "chest out" pose rather than really owning it. This is something watch for, as it still feels a bit much now, but I have the feeling that it'll be really cool if and only I genuinely commit to it.

Wednesday, November 3, 2010

Mostly approved :)

Greg approved the kid and coach in the image below during tonight's Q&A. The relatively minor notes are to scoot the kid's body backwards a bit, have the coach hold the clipboard in his hand rather than in the crook of his elbow, and raise the coach's head while lowering his eyeline a bit. I also plan on scaling the box, not too much but enough to make it easier to handle.

Right this instant, I'm just plain relieved that this two-week Saga of Frame 1 is nearing its conclusion! Gotta love animation and all its mountain-sized molehills! (Molehill-sized mountains?)

Tuesday, November 2, 2010

Need help

Kind of losing my mind a bit on just one pose. This is a screenshot of a comment on my own WS where I tried to spell out the problem, though I haven't gotten much of a response yet.

Basically, I feel like I'm running across the unhittable note, where I don't like my original pose, I'm not wild about a literal interpretation of what my mentor drew (though it's an obvious improvement), and any more radical departure feels like insubordination. Anyone have any suggestions? Of the four variations I posted at the very bottom of the page, I actually prefer the first (spine entirely reversed) and feel that the second is truest to the original pose.

Sunday, October 31, 2010

Week 5

This week was strange. I actually got my eCrit BEFORE the assignment deadline! I'd submitted it on Saturday night, but assumed I'd have Sunday morning to make last-minute changes and edit my notes to mentor. Instead, Greg leaped in at around 11:50, before my final upload. It turned out not to matter much, but somehow left me feeling jumpy and unsettled.

A recap of the good things that happened this week: I had some great Skype sessions with Yannick regarding body mechanics, and I ordered Wayne Gilbert's book Simplified Drawing for Planning Animation off http://www.anamie.com (it's $29.95 there, but for some reason used copies on Amazon start at $200.00). I really feel like after all this time, some of the subtleties (and obviousities) of body mechanics are finally starting to click. At the same time, my personal health has been good - I've been going to the gym and eating well. I wouldn't keep harping on this point, except I think personal health does play a huge role in whether or not you survive AM - it's so easy to neglect exercise, nutrition, and sleep.

And now for the bad news: Greg wasn't at all happy that I focused on the kid's bench leap this week rather than addressing his notes from last week for the first 60 frames. Truth is, I struggled, second-guessed myself, and then finally switched off to a more stable section of my shot for the sake of not wasting a week.

In hindsight, I think I psyched myself out. All he was really asking for was ONE key pose for each character. For whatever reason, I a) really struggled with the kid's pose because I was afraid to stretch the arms, and b) FIXATED on whether or not adjusting the way the coach holds his clipboard was too big a change.

This next week is make-it-or-break-it. I really need to pick up the pace, and in order to do that, I need to to just trust myself. I was going to type out a longer summary of the eCrit and other notes, but I realized as I was typing that the bigger theme here is that I need to quit second-guessing myself and just attack the shot and Greg's notes wholeheartedly. I know what needs to be done, now I need to just go out and do it.

Tuesday, October 26, 2010

Week 4 Assignment

My computer finally seems stable, and I posted my Week 4 assignment along with a summary of my eCrit. Didn't have the energy to wrestle with Quicktime codecs, though I promised Erin I'd try.

Sunday, October 24, 2010

My Computer Is Suicidal

Crashes and freezing all week, despite my best efforts at swapping out hardware. I'm worried that this machine won't last the term. I was probably going to buy a laptop before the end of the term anyway, to take advantage of student discounts, but I hate having my timetable accelerated by external events.

I just submitted this week's assignment for AM, but I'm going to wait till tomorrow evening to update the blog because it's late, I'm tired, I hate my computer, and it hates me.

Sunday, October 17, 2010

Physicality

I don't want to become one of those people who posts photos of every meal on Facebook, but I do feel that taking charge of food and exercise is going to be a key part of getting through this final term. I finally joined a gym towards the end of last term. I didn't want to spend the money initially, but allergy-related frustrations left me feeling awful physically, to the point where it was messing with my emotional well-being.

Enter gym.

I spent the past month or so just doing cardio, but am now using my three free trainer sessions to start getting back into weights again. And this time around, I'm amazed at how AnimationMentor has shaped that experience too. The first time I tried working with weights, about two years ago, I was actually pretty amazed - I assumed I'd hate it, but once I got over the initial confusion, it was a better anatomy lesson than any art class could ever provide. When you work to develop a muscle and it feels sore the next day, you remember exactly where that muscle is and what it does.

This time around, I'm also fascinated watching myself in the mirror and observing all the little things the body does for balance and counterbalance and resistance. After studying animation, it really is impossible to ever go back to seeing the world the old way again.

Week 3 Submission

Goodbye door, hello clipboard. I'm very, very happy with the direction Greg's taken me so far, but also getting worn out by the constant reblocking.

There's no point in polishing until the work is ready to be polished, but it's it's hard not to feel like I'm running to stand still sometimes. Hopefully, I can pick up the pace in the next few weeks as the shot solidifies. I'm actually really looking forward to going back to the facial animation and working on the lip sync, but there's no point in doing that until the body's working.

Wednesday, October 13, 2010

Student Comments

Definitely going for the clipboard for the coach as a replacement for the door. Now for some of the comments from fellow students:


From Ellie:

Frame 92 the coach's right arm should keep going down. seems to be stuck in air.

Frame 251 would be the most I'd have the kid's whole body rotate to the screen left. This will probably help with the direction of the kid's attention around frame 298.

Make sure to maintain eye direction especially around frame 179 on.



From Leo:

Hi An-Lon,
I also like that we get to see the kid. This staging both simplified the scene and is a stronger staging, with a clearer scene direction and character flow. There's some slight adjustments which I'd like to see if they improve the scene:

Perhaps reframe the camera so the kid's shoes are seen in the beginning. To keep the coach's head in the shot it might mean backing off with the camera slightly or going to a shorter lens (meaning more distortion, especially in objects close to the camera).
As it's staged now the kid's ankles are cropped, which I reacted visually to.
On F204 the coach's head has an unfortunate tangent to the frame of the picture plane. Either crop his head more or show it all.
Now it is cropped yet not, visually. Tangents are a visual pain because they confuse the read of the shapes, confusing one shape (the head in this case) with the frame, the eye traveling along the tangent created (the frame) instead of staying with what you want the audience to look at (the coach).
296 works because the crop is so clear it so there's no confusion as to what happens to the coach.
353 could have an even more extreme happy reaction from the kid. After all, this is a dream come true for the kid, I take it?

Are you allowed to do camera moves?
If you are imagine a line between the coach's shoulders to the kid's shoulder.
Then start the scene with the camera in the coaches shoulder height (the camera's position just adjust the height), looking down at the kid, suppressing the kid's visual status.
Then as the kid gets the good news, gently, as invisibly and subtly as you can, track left and down, stopping (easing into) the camera that you have now at F243. Maybe even a touch lower, looking up at the kid and the coach, giving the kid a new found status in the scene.

Hope this made sense! Hit me with questions or thoughts :)
Leo

PS By the way, if you want to learn much more about camera, staging and layout work study these in detail and in this order:
Hollywood camera works DVDs
Film Directing Shot by Shot by Steven Katz
On Film-making by Alexander Mackendrick
They'll give you a well rounded view in creating a conscious filmic language.
The Visual Story by Bruce Block is also a good read but more on the visual side of production design.
In the Blink of an Eye, Walter Murch is a fun read on editing though not so many practical suggestions.

There's also some fine art books on the subject of composition that have helped inform my thinking
though you'd have to apply the theories on sequential compositions as opposed to stills.
I even use some Feng Shui theories on my compositions just to mix things up.
The fine art books are
Mastering composition by Ian Roberts
Mastering composition by Glenn Vilppu
Composing pictures by Donald Graham.

But I'd especially start with Hollywood camera works DVDs. Worth ever penny and should be mandatory for every film maker.
Just don't fall asleep on them ;)



From Allyssa:






From Jasbeer:

just a quick email to say I have watched the new version. the camera look so much better. The tricky part now is the coach because i can se you trying to keep part of his face visble to the camera.

maybe you can have him say the part of the dialogue almost like a monologue to the camera and when the kid reacts, you cut, and he turns to look at the kid skipping over the bench and running toward him

then cut back to angle looking at the kid over the coach shoulder, who then turns to face caemra and walk out.

I think if you lock down the camera/layout then everything will fall into its place. at the moment the twisting of coach feels a bit uncomfortable. but loving the little guy

Tuesday, October 12, 2010

Week 2 eCrit

Here's a summary of Greg's eCrit. This is a 10-minute recorded spiel that's available for me and anyone on the site to watch. Likewise, I can also watch anyone else's eCrit and that's another great way to learn. I also have some workspace comments from friends I should probably post here, but I'm still trying to prioritize those.

The goal is generally to hit mentor notes first, since s/he's your director, but there have definitely been times when students pointed out something a mentor didn't, or said the exact same thing in a way that somehow clicked better, so I'm happy to get whatever feedback I can.

Next step is NOT to leap back into Maya, but rather do some sketching. Exploring ideas on paper is an awful lot cheaper than wandering around endlessly in Maya.



1) Kid's too busy in the beginning, it's distracting and redundant. Pick a hero pose for the dejected look and stay there. Get a nice pose reading to camera, strong silhouette, also full of attitude, let audience connect.

Make sure there's a lot of contrast between that pose and the next hero pose around 140, when he's more alert and gets that glimmer of hope. Second pose needs to be much more alert, upright, full of life. Stay within that second pose for a longer beat as well - a beat or half a beat before he puts the box down and leaps over the bench.

2) Jump feels better, more bounce to little boy, exaggerated ups and downs makes a huge difference.

3) Go for a straight leg on screen right leg at 201 in anticipation of the landing. Straight leg needs to read for more than one frame. As he lands, would be nice to see more of a bend to the leg, change in shape, feel the weight. See straight leg in live action reference. Consider re-shooting reference from new camera angle.

4) Keep hand planted on bench more through middle part of jump. Shouldn't be a lot of sliding when his weight's on it.

5) Coach's performance: We no longer see enough of the doorknob. Do something different with his hands, maybe using a new prop. Maybe fumbling with the keyring or a piece of sporting equipment. Don't want it to be distracting, don't change a lot of the existing animation, just do something that reads better than the doorknob.

6) Walking offscreen is fine, don't need to convey the sense of moving through a door. Exit in profile might be nice, rather than coming toward camera and growing in frame. Re-entering frame can be along that same angle.

7) Maintain eyelines, kid doesn't really look focused on coach.

8) Right now the boy's approach upon landing after the bench leap works. May still be cheated, but right now it's working with the new camera. Don't change that section too much (207-235).

9) Would be nice to see coach stay within a pose as boy delivers his line between 270 and 290. Delay the turn and walk away, right now it happens immediately and is distracting.

10) At any point where both characters are moving at the same time and attention should clearly be on one character, make sure the other character's movement is not competing. Obvious way to do that is to limit the movement.

11) Should be really pleased with these changes. Night and day compared with last week, huge step in right direction.

Sunday, October 10, 2010

Wing and a Prayer

Just submitted my assignment for this week, with the camera change. See Week 2 tab for the final result and note to mentor.

The revision process actually wasn't nearly as bad as I'd feared. Obviously, I still have a ways to go, but all the problems feel more solvable now. In hindsight, the eyeline problems that persisted from week to week during Class 5 were to a large extent caused by the cameras. I'm not sure yet whether the new camera introduces new problems, but this week's surgery felt like an exercise in uncheating and uncontorting. Regardless of whether it ends up as my final camera, it's a very useful mastershot.

Wednesday, October 6, 2010

Camera Surgery

Major changes forthcoming, and it's going to lead to the animation being a mess for a while. Greg suggested changing the cameras - more specifically, ditching the first and third, and using the second for the entire shot. I think this is the right move, as there were some staging and eyeline problems that just REFUSED to go away under the old cameras. But committing to this route means the animation is going to get worse before it gets better, so I may not be at a good stopping point to post updates for a while - it's something of an all-or-nothing rather than incremental change. I have to submit something for next week's assignment, which is now only three days away, but it might not be pretty. The following week should be better, as I'll have momentum.

I actually went through this once before with the juggler. After the term ended, I took two weeks over Christmas break to consolidate three cuts that weren't working into one that was. Basically, switching to a new camera forced me to fix major problems that had been caused by cheating to the old camera, and allowed the animation to hold up much better in 3D space.

I hadn't expected to have to do that again for the Class 5 shot, and it's a big mountain to tackle, but right this instant, I'm feeling more relieved than anything else. The camera change exposed major body mechanics problems in some areas, but also fixed or made fixable some staging and eyeline issues that had stayed stubbornly intractable all last term. We'll see what happens in the next two weeks! If this goes well, I'll be thrilled to move onto the facial animation and tackling the lip sync problems. But first things first. One week at a time.