Here's a summary of Greg's eCrit. This is a 10-minute recorded spiel that's available for me and anyone on the site to watch. Likewise, I can also watch anyone else's eCrit and that's another great way to learn. I also have some workspace comments from friends I should probably post here, but I'm still trying to prioritize those.
The goal is generally to hit mentor notes first, since s/he's your director, but there have definitely been times when students pointed out something a mentor didn't, or said the exact same thing in a way that somehow clicked better, so I'm happy to get whatever feedback I can.
Next step is NOT to leap back into Maya, but rather do some sketching. Exploring ideas on paper is an awful lot cheaper than wandering around endlessly in Maya.
1) Kid's too busy in the beginning, it's distracting and redundant. Pick a hero pose for the dejected look and stay there. Get a nice pose reading to camera, strong silhouette, also full of attitude, let audience connect.
Make sure there's a lot of contrast between that pose and the next hero pose around 140, when he's more alert and gets that glimmer of hope. Second pose needs to be much more alert, upright, full of life. Stay within that second pose for a longer beat as well - a beat or half a beat before he puts the box down and leaps over the bench.
2) Jump feels better, more bounce to little boy, exaggerated ups and downs makes a huge difference.
3) Go for a straight leg on screen right leg at 201 in anticipation of the landing. Straight leg needs to read for more than one frame. As he lands, would be nice to see more of a bend to the leg, change in shape, feel the weight. See straight leg in live action reference. Consider re-shooting reference from new camera angle.
4) Keep hand planted on bench more through middle part of jump. Shouldn't be a lot of sliding when his weight's on it.
5) Coach's performance: We no longer see enough of the doorknob. Do something different with his hands, maybe using a new prop. Maybe fumbling with the keyring or a piece of sporting equipment. Don't want it to be distracting, don't change a lot of the existing animation, just do something that reads better than the doorknob.
6) Walking offscreen is fine, don't need to convey the sense of moving through a door. Exit in profile might be nice, rather than coming toward camera and growing in frame. Re-entering frame can be along that same angle.
7) Maintain eyelines, kid doesn't really look focused on coach.
8) Right now the boy's approach upon landing after the bench leap works. May still be cheated, but right now it's working with the new camera. Don't change that section too much (207-235).
9) Would be nice to see coach stay within a pose as boy delivers his line between 270 and 290. Delay the turn and walk away, right now it happens immediately and is distracting.
10) At any point where both characters are moving at the same time and attention should clearly be on one character, make sure the other character's movement is not competing. Obvious way to do that is to limit the movement.
11) Should be really pleased with these changes. Night and day compared with last week, huge step in right direction.
No comments:
Post a Comment