Pages


Wednesday, October 13, 2010

Student Comments

Definitely going for the clipboard for the coach as a replacement for the door. Now for some of the comments from fellow students:


From Ellie:

Frame 92 the coach's right arm should keep going down. seems to be stuck in air.

Frame 251 would be the most I'd have the kid's whole body rotate to the screen left. This will probably help with the direction of the kid's attention around frame 298.

Make sure to maintain eye direction especially around frame 179 on.



From Leo:

Hi An-Lon,
I also like that we get to see the kid. This staging both simplified the scene and is a stronger staging, with a clearer scene direction and character flow. There's some slight adjustments which I'd like to see if they improve the scene:

Perhaps reframe the camera so the kid's shoes are seen in the beginning. To keep the coach's head in the shot it might mean backing off with the camera slightly or going to a shorter lens (meaning more distortion, especially in objects close to the camera).
As it's staged now the kid's ankles are cropped, which I reacted visually to.
On F204 the coach's head has an unfortunate tangent to the frame of the picture plane. Either crop his head more or show it all.
Now it is cropped yet not, visually. Tangents are a visual pain because they confuse the read of the shapes, confusing one shape (the head in this case) with the frame, the eye traveling along the tangent created (the frame) instead of staying with what you want the audience to look at (the coach).
296 works because the crop is so clear it so there's no confusion as to what happens to the coach.
353 could have an even more extreme happy reaction from the kid. After all, this is a dream come true for the kid, I take it?

Are you allowed to do camera moves?
If you are imagine a line between the coach's shoulders to the kid's shoulder.
Then start the scene with the camera in the coaches shoulder height (the camera's position just adjust the height), looking down at the kid, suppressing the kid's visual status.
Then as the kid gets the good news, gently, as invisibly and subtly as you can, track left and down, stopping (easing into) the camera that you have now at F243. Maybe even a touch lower, looking up at the kid and the coach, giving the kid a new found status in the scene.

Hope this made sense! Hit me with questions or thoughts :)
Leo

PS By the way, if you want to learn much more about camera, staging and layout work study these in detail and in this order:
Hollywood camera works DVDs
Film Directing Shot by Shot by Steven Katz
On Film-making by Alexander Mackendrick
They'll give you a well rounded view in creating a conscious filmic language.
The Visual Story by Bruce Block is also a good read but more on the visual side of production design.
In the Blink of an Eye, Walter Murch is a fun read on editing though not so many practical suggestions.

There's also some fine art books on the subject of composition that have helped inform my thinking
though you'd have to apply the theories on sequential compositions as opposed to stills.
I even use some Feng Shui theories on my compositions just to mix things up.
The fine art books are
Mastering composition by Ian Roberts
Mastering composition by Glenn Vilppu
Composing pictures by Donald Graham.

But I'd especially start with Hollywood camera works DVDs. Worth ever penny and should be mandatory for every film maker.
Just don't fall asleep on them ;)



From Allyssa:






From Jasbeer:

just a quick email to say I have watched the new version. the camera look so much better. The tricky part now is the coach because i can se you trying to keep part of his face visble to the camera.

maybe you can have him say the part of the dialogue almost like a monologue to the camera and when the kid reacts, you cut, and he turns to look at the kid skipping over the bench and running toward him

then cut back to angle looking at the kid over the coach shoulder, who then turns to face caemra and walk out.

I think if you lock down the camera/layout then everything will fall into its place. at the moment the twisting of coach feels a bit uncomfortable. but loving the little guy

No comments:

Post a Comment